Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest in Greece – LETTER TO THE EDITORS

We congratulate the authors on their study, through which our country was able to be one of the 26 countries participating in EuReCa-THREE, this important study of the European Resuscitation Council (ERC)1.

Over the years, serious efforts have been made at EKAB Thessaloniki to register cardiac arrests, but without continuity. The same inherent difficulties exist at the European level: over a period of approximately a decade, ERC coducted three studies (EuReCa ONE, EuReCa TWO and EuReCa-THREE), each covering a defined time window (of one and three months, respectively); not all countries participated, and none of these studies was continued on an ongoing basis1-3.

In EuReCa-THREE, our country participated with patients from a single region only (in contrast to the preceding EuReCa ONE and EuReCa TWO); the results are therefore more homogeneous and reflect the functioning of EKAB Thessaloniki.

As stated in your article, the aim was to present the particular characteristics of cardiac arrests that occurred during the EuReCa-THREE study period and were managed by EKAB Thessaloniki4.

In the light of these data, in our opinion it would be of particular interest, if you could present the following, provided the relevant data are available:

  • Why was CPR initiated or continued in such a small proportion of cases (32.8%), and who (physician or paramedic) made the decision as to whether or not it should be performed?
  • Your study (probably not in purpose) does not report any data on the mobile intensive care units, for which EKAB Thessaloniki has a long-standing tradition, since they have existed since its foundation.
  • Given that the prehospital emergency care system in Greece is a two-tiered one, it would be of interest, if relevant data are available, to know in how many of these patients advanced life support (ALS) was delivered by an EKAB mobile intensive care unit, as well as what the response times were.
  • After the 2004 Olympic Games, automated external defibrillators (AEDs) have been included in the basic equipment of standard ambulances, and in our opinion they play an important role in the management of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.

It would be of particular interest to know in how many of the cardiac arrests, AED was used, and whether there were patients who achieved return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) before the arrival of the mobile intensive care unit.

  • The locations in which cardiac arrest occurred included home and workplace. Were any patients recorded, who suffered cardiac arrest in a public place and, if so, in which of the two categories are they included?
  • Given the deployment of public-access AEDs in public places, it would be of interest to have data on this subcategory, as well as on whether there were any patients in whom defibrillation was delivered by bystanders using an AED.
  • In an earlier unpublished registry at EKAB Thessaloniki involving more than 2,000 patients, higher rates of ROSC, and survival to hospital discharge of more than 10%, were recorded in the patients who received CPR from EKAB. What would be here a possible explanation?
  • Given that EKAB is able to deliver high-quality CPR comparable to that delivered in hospital, it would be of interest to know whether any of the patients transported with ongoing CPR and without ROSC survived.
  • The high rate of bystander CPR is of interest; since, however, it is not accompanied by an increase in the survival rate, a separate evaluation of the quality of these resuscitation attempts would be required.

Systematic and continuous registration of cardiac arrests, and not only in the context of participation in a multicenter study, would help in evaluating the health services provided by EKAB and in taking measures to improve them.

More info
Γλώσσα
Αναβάθμιση του Impact Factor

Ιστορικό
ATOM Feed
RSS Feed
RDF Feed
Άδεια Creative Commons